Lyu, Park, Lee, Jeon, Jung, and Park: A Systemic Review of Clinical Trials Using Medication for Acute Bronchitis: A Pre-study on the Development of Traditional Korean Medicine Clinical Practice Guideline
Original Article
The Journal of Korean Medicine 2017; 38(1): 93-111.
A Systemic Review of Clinical Trials Using Medication for Acute Bronchitis: A Pre-study on the Development of Traditional Korean Medicine Clinical Practice Guideline
The aim of this study is to make evidence-based data for developing a traditional Korean medicine clinical practice guideline for acute bronchitis.
Methods
We searched 3 international databases(PubMed, EMBASE, CENTRAL) and 7 domestic databases (KoreaMed, Kmbase, NDSL, KISS, KISTI, OASIS, KoreaTK) to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of acute bronchitis using medicine in recent 10 years. The chosen trials were analyzed by their study design, age range, intervention group, control group, primary and second outcome measure, inclusion and exclusion of participants and adverse events.
Results
15 RCTs are finally included in this study and most of their medications are herbal medicine. For diagnosis and outcome measure of acute bronchitis, Bronchitis Severity Score(BSS) was mostly used. Other measurements eligible are coughing fits, quality of life scale, sputum viscosity, change of individual symptoms and patient’s satisfaction. Test duration was for average 7days and safety assessment was held by recording adverse events. Except for anti-inflammatory and antibiotic trials, all medications are found to be effective and well-tolerated. General risk of bias of chosen trials is evaluated low.
Conclusions
A well designed clinical trials for traditional Korean medicine of acute bronchitis is needed and this study is expected to make it available.
Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria of the Studies Included in the Review
First author (Year)
Study design
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Cwientzek U (2011)
double-blind, randomized study
at least 2 years of age with a confirmed clinical diagnosis of acute bronchitis
a baseline BSS ≥ 5 points
duration of not more than 48 h
previous medications which may influence the course of the study indication or the evaluation of the target criteria, such as these stated under “Concomitant therapy”.
patients with concomitant diseases like allergic asthma or bronchial hyper reactivity, chronic bronchitis, other chronic or inherited lung diseases, or severe cardiac, hepatic, or renal disorders
Ding H (2010)
multicenter, double blind, double dummy, randomized and parallel positive drug controlled
18–65 years old
diagnosed with wind-heat syndrome (Chinese medicine symptom score≥ 5)
diagnosed with acute upper respiratory infection or acute bronchitis
within 48hours for acute upper respiratory infection; within 5days from onset for acute bronchitis
symptom severity with mild or moderate, body temperature below 38.5°C
consent to participate
take previous west medication within 2weeks for UTRI
have severe medical conditions with relevant influence on the acute bronchitis
Gillissen A (2013)
double-blind, parallel-group fashion
at least 18 years of age
Brocaindex between 0.75 and 1.30
clinical diagnosis of acute bronchitis as characterized by: ≥ 10 coughing fits during the last day
a baseline BSS ≥ 5 points
on set of first symptoms (bronchial mucus production with impaired ability to cough up) within 2 days before the start of the investigational treatment.
history or presence of confounding respiratory disease (e.g. upper respiratory tract infection within the last 4 weeks, chronic bronchitis or COPD or acute exacerbations of bronchiectasis, asthma, suspected pneumonia, cystic fibrosis, lung cancer);
concomitant bacterial infection
elevated body temperature(>39.5°C rectally or >39.0°C axillary or otic)
active cigarette smoking > 1 pack per day
hypersensitivity to the trial medication
inflammatory gastrointestinal or hepatic disease or inflammation of the gallbladder or bile duct, history or presence of clinically relevant cardiovascular, renal, metabolic, hematological, dermatologic, neurological, psychiatric, systemic or infectious disease
pregnancy or breast feeding, women of childbearing potential without highly effective contraception (failure rate<1%)
participation in a clinical research study within the last 6 weeks
evidence or suspicion of non-compliance, inability to provide informed consent.
Hu S.-Y. (2016)
random, open, parallel-group controlled, and multi-center clinical studies
diagnosed with acute bronchitis for child
diagnosed with wind-heat syndrome
aged 1–13 years old
symptoms starting within 72h, not yet used antibiotics, antitussive, expectorants and any other drugs that could affect test medication
body temperature within 24h from baseline ≤ 38.5°C
granulocytosis(e.g. suspected bacterial infection), severe heart, renal or liver diseases, immunosuppression
known or supposed hypersensitivity to trial medication
evidence or suspicion of non-compliance
Kamin W (2010)
randomized, double-blind, placebo controlled clinical dose-finding study with 4 parallel treatment groups
aged 6–18 years old
acute bronchitis with symptoms starting within 48h
BSS≥5 points at screening
treatment with antibiotics, bronchodilators or glucocorticoids during the last 4 weeks, or with analgetics, secretolytics, mucolytics or antitussive during the last 7 days prior to study inclusion
indication for treatment with antibiotics
allergic asthma, tendency to bleed, severe heart, renal or liver diseases and/or immunosuppression, known hypersensitivity against P. sidoides, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and pregnancy.
Kamin W’ (2010)
double-blind randomized clinical trial
aged 1–18 years suffering from acute bronchitis
symptoms starting 48 hours prior to inclusion into the study
BSS≥5points at screening
treatment with antibiotics
allergic asthma, COPD, tendency to bleed, severe heart, renal or liver diseases and/or immunosuppression;
known hypersensitivity against Pelargonium sidoides
symptoms starting 48h prior to inclusion in the study
BSS≥5points at screening
concomitant medication that may impair the study results (e.g. antibiotics, bronchodilators, glucocorticoids, analgesics other than paracetamol, secretolytics, mycolytics, anti-tussiva, or other bronchitis medication)
allergic asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, tendency to bleed, severe heart, renal or liver diseases and/or immunosuppression
known hypersensitivity to Pelargonium sidoides
pregnancy
Kemmerich B(2007)
double-blind, placebo controlled, multicenter Phase IV study
at least 18 years of age,
≥10 coughing fits during the day
onset of bronchial mucus production with impaired ability to cough up at a maximum of 2 days prior to recruitment
BSS ≥ 5points at screening
pregnancy, no contraception for women of child bearing age and lactation for females
the principal ones being concomitant fever(> 39 °C)
pneumonia, history of chronic bronchial or pulmonary disease such as chronic bronchitis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (including acute episode), bronchiectasis, bronchial asthma, mucoviscidosis, history of clinically relevant chronic cardiovascular, kidney, gastrointestinal or liver disease, known hypersensitivity to one or more of the active or inactive ingredients of the investigational product, malignant growth, or any severe somatopathic, neurological and/or psychiatric disease.
treatment with other drugs, such as immunosuppressives, systemic antibiotics and systemic or inhaled glucocorticosteroids (within 4 weeks prior to enrolment into the study or concomitantly), mucoactive substances other than the study medication(within 2 weeks prior to enrolment or concomitantly), antitussive drugs and other mucoactive measures except for steam inhalation were not allowed
treatment with angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors was no reason for exclusion if started more than 4 weeks prior to Visit(Paracetamol could be taken in case of fever, other non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs were not allowed during the study)
Lior C (2013)
Parallel group, single blinded, placebo controlled randomized clinical trial
aged 18 to 70 without associated respiratory comorbidity or immunosuppression
respiratory tract infection of less than one week’s duration
with cough as the predominant symptom and discolored sputum and at least one other criterion of lower respiratory tract infection such as dyspnea, wheezing, chest discomfort, or chest pain
antibiotic, anti-inflammatory, or corticosteroid use in the previous two weeks
the presence of radiological signs of pneumonia; signs of severe infection such as confusion
respiratory rate >25 breaths per minute or pulse >120 beats per minute
history of gastrointestinal hemorrhage or intolerance to anti-inflammatory treatment
hypersensitivity to β lactams or intolerance to clavulanic acid or lactose
pregnancy, lactation, and absence of contraception in women of fertile age
associated comorbidity (bronchial asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, moderate-severe heart failure, dementia, stroke, immunosuppression or the use of immunosuppressive drugs)
emergency situation
in residential care; unable to provide informed consent; difficulty in attending the programmed visits; previous participation in the study; and refusal to participate.
acute bronchitis with symptoms starting within 48h
BSS ≥ 5 points at screening
indication of antibiotic treatment or treatment with antibiotics during the 4-weeks prior to enrolment in the trial
allergic bronchial asthma, tendency to bleed, severe heart, renal or liver diseases, immunosuppression, known or supposed hypersensitivity to trial medication
concomitant medication that might affect trial results or interact with the study medication(e.g. antibiotics)
participation in another clinical trial during the preceding 3 months and patients irresponsible of unable to understand the nature of the study
participation in any other trial at the same time or within 4 weeks prior to study inclusion
indication for antibiotic treatment, suspected pneumonia
treatment with antibiotics, ACE-inhibitors, β-blockers, bronchodilators, or glucocorticoids within 4 weeks prior to study inclusion
treatment with analgesics, secretolytics, mucolytics, or antitussives during the 7 days prior to study inclusion
allergic bronchial asthma, concomitant bacterial disease or diseases of the upper respiratory tract tendency to bleed, severe heart, renal, or liver diseases and/or immunosuppression
if patients had a fever(39°C), they were allowed to take 500mg paracetamol tablets, but no more than three tablets daily
Nduba VN (2008)
a triple blind, randomized, equivalence trial
aged >18 years old
presenting with a productive cough of 2 weeks duration
another potential explanation for cough (history of chronic bronchitis, allergic rhinitis, sinusitis, asthma or gastric reflux),
serious medical comorbidity (heart disease or diabetes), penicillin allergy, antibiotic use in the preceding 2 weeks or a concurrent infection (including tuberculosis) requiring antibiotic treatment.
indication for antibiotic treatment, treatment with antibiotics during the past four weeks before inclusion in the trial
allergic bronchial asthma, tendency to bleed, severe heart, renal, or liver diseases, immunosuppression, known or supposed hypersensitivity to the investigational medication
concomitant medication that might impair the study results(eg, antibiotics) or supposed interactions of the concomitant medication with the investigational medication
participation in another clinical trial during the past three months
patients who are known or suspected by their mental capability to be noncompliant
having undergone antibiotic treatment within 7 days prior to enrollment in the study
use of antitussive agents or any other medication that might positively or negatively affect the cough symptom.
참고문헌
1. 2016 Statistical Indicator of Medical Expenses. Health Insurance Review & Assessment service;(2017). p. 1-16.
2. Mudarri, DH. Valuing the Economic Costs of Allergic Rhinitis, Acute Bronchitis, and Asthma from Exposure to Indoor Dampness and Mold in the US. Journal of Environmental and Public Health, (2016). 2016, 2386596.
3. Eom, SJ. Essentials of Primary Care: Respiratory: The most common disease of Koreans, Acute bronchitis. The Korean Association of International Medicine Sping Conference Collection, (2016). 2016, 122-5.
4. Albert, RH. Diagnosis and treatment of acute bronchitis. Am Fam Physician, (2010). 82(11), 1345-50.
5. Pratter, MR. Cough and the common cold: ACCP evidence-based clinical practice guidelines. Chest, (2006). 129, 72S-4S.
10. Gonzales, R, Bartlett, JG, Besser, RE, Cooper, RJ, Hickner, JM, Hoffman, JR, & Sande, MA. Principles of appropriate antibiotic use for treatment of uncomplicated acute bronchitis: background. Annals of Internal Medicine, (2001). 134(6), 521-529.
11. Tackett, KL, & Atkins, A. Evidence-based acute bronchitis therapy. Journal of pharmacy practice, (2012). 0897190012460826.
12. Braman, SS. Chronic cough due to acute bronchitis: ACCP evidence-based clinical practice guidelines. Chest, (2006). 129(suppl 1), 95S-103S.
13. Knutson, D, & Braun, C. Diagnosis and management of acute bronchitis. Am Fam Physician, (2002). 65(10), 2039-2044.
14. Becker, LA, Hom, J, Villasis-Keever, M, & van der Wouden, JC. Beta2-agonists for acute cough or a clinical diagnosis of acute bronchitis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, (2015.
15. Jiang, L, Li, K, & Wu, T. Chinese medicinal herbs for acute bronchitis. The Cochrane Library, (2012.
16. Higgins, JPT, Altman, DG, Gøtzsche, PC, Jüni, P, Moher, D, Oxman, AD, & Sterne, JA, et al. The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. Bmj, 343, (2011). d5928.
17. Higgins, JPT, Altman, DG, & Sterne, JAC. Chapter 8: Assessing risk of bias in included studies. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, (2011.
18. Kinkade, S, & Natalie, AL. Acute Bronchitis. American Family Physician, 94, 7. (2016.
19. Lehrl, S, Matthys, H, Kamin, W, & Kardos, P. The BSS—a valid clinical instrument to measure the severity of acute bronchitis. Pulm Respir Res, 1, (2014). 00016.
20. Matthys, H, & Kamin, W. Positioning of the Bronchitis Severity Score (BSS) for standardised use in clinical studies. Current medical research and opinion, 29(10), (2013). 1383-1390.
21. Cwientzek, U, Bertram, O, & Petr, A. Acute bronchitis therapy with ivy leaves extracts in a two-arm study. A double-blind, randomised study vs. an other ivy leaves extract. Phytomedicine, 18(13), (2011). 1105-1109.
22. Ding, H, Yang, Mj, Lv, B, Dong, Y, Li, Xj, & Luo, Wj, et al. A Multicentered, Double-blind, Randomized Controlled Trials of Gankeshuangqing Capsule in the Treatment of Wind-heat Syndrome (Acute Upper Respiratory Infection or Acute Bronchitis). Chinese journal of evidence-based medicine, (2010). 10(1), 14-22.
23. Fischer, J, & Dethlefsen, U. Efficacy of cineole in patients suffering from acute bronchitis: a placebo-controlled double-blind trial. Cough, (2013). 9(1), 25.
24. Gillissen, A, Wittig, T, Ehmen, M, Krezdorn, HG, & de Mey, C. A multi-centre, randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial on the efficacy and tolerability of GeloMyrtol® forte in acute bronchitis. Drug research, 63(01), (2013). 19-27.
25. Hu, SY, Li, JH, Tang, F, Cheng, Y, Zhang, YM, & Zhang, PP, et al. Clinical observation of Qingfei Xiaoyan Pill in treatment of lung phlegm heat syndrome in children with acute bronchitis. [Chinese]. Chinese Traditional and Herbal Drugs, (2016). 47(10), 1746-9.
26. Kamin, W, Maydannik, VG, Malek, FA, & Kieser, M. Efficacy and tolerability of EPs 7630 in patients (aged 6–18 years old) with acute bronchitis. Acta Paediatrica, 99(4), (2010). 537-543.
27. Kamin, W, Maydannik, V, Malek, FA, & Kieser, M. Efficacy and tolerability of EPs 7630 in children and adolescents with acute bronchitis-a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled multicenter trial with a herbal drug preparation from Pelargonium sidoides roots. International journal of clinical pharmacology and therapeutics, 48(3), (2010). 184-191.
28. Kamin, W, Ilyenko, LI, Malek, FA, & Kieser, M. Treatment of acute bronchitis with EPs 7630: randomized, controlled trial in children and adolescents. Pediatrics International, 54(2), (2012). 219-226.
29. Kemmerich, B. Evaluation of Efficacy and Tolerability of a Fixed Combination of Dry Extracts of Thyme Herb and Primrose Root in Adults Suffering from Acute Bronchitis with Productive Cough. Arzneimittelforschung, 57(09), (2007). 607-615.
30. Llor, C, Moragas, A, Bayona, C, Morros, R, Pera, H, Plana-Ripoll, O, & Miravitlles, M, et al. Efficacy of anti-inflammatory or antibiotic treatment in patients with non-complicated acute bronchitis and discoloured sputum: randomised placebo controlled trial. bmj, 347, (2013). f5762.
31. Matthys, H, & Heger, M. Treatment of acute bronchitis with a liquid herbal drug preparation from Pelargonium sidoides (EPs 7630): a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multicentre study. Current medical research and opinion, 23(2), (2007). 323-331.
32. Matthys, H, Lizogub, VG, Malek, FA, & Kieser, M. Efficacy and tolerability of EPs 7630 tablets in patients with acute bronchitis: a randomised, double-blind, placebo -controlled dose-finding study with a herbal drug preparation from Pelargonium si doides. Current medical research and opinion, 26(6), (2010). 1413-1422.
33. Nduba, VN, Mwachari, CW, Magaret, AS, Park, DR, Kigo, A, Hooton, TM, & Cohen, CR. Placebo found equivalent to amoxicillin for treatment of acute bronchitis in Nairobi, Kenya: a triple blind, randomised, equivalence trial. Thorax, 63(11), (2008). 999-1005.
34. Schulz, V. Liquid herbal drug preparation from the root of Pelargonium sidoides is effective against acute bronchitis: results of a double-blind study with 124 patients. Phytomedicine, 14, (2007). 74-75.
35. Zanasi, A, Mazzolini, M, Tursi, F, Morselli-Labate, AM, Paccapelo, A, & Lecchi, M. Homeopathic medicine for acute cough in upper respiratory tract infections and acute bronchitis: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Pulmonary pharmacology & therapeutics, 27(1), (2014). 102-108.
36. Traditional Korean Medicine Clinical Practice Guideline -Antitussive and Protussive Therapy. Korea Food & Drug Administration;(2006). p. 1-21.
37. Kim, KI, Lee, HJ, Lee, BJ, Jung, HJ, Jung, SK, & Lee, JH. Analysis of Recent Clinical Studies to Establish Korean Herbal Medicine Clinical Trial Guidelines for the Common Cold. J Int Korean Med, (2016). 37(1), 109-134.
38. The Korean Academy of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases. Respiratory Diseases. 3rd rev ed. Soeul. Koonja publishing INC;(2007). p. 695-703.
39. Kardos, P, Lehrl, S, Kamin, W, & Matthys, H. Assessment of the effect of pharmacotherapy in common cold/acute bronchitis–the Bronchitis Severity Scale (BSS). Pneumologie, 68(08), (2014). 542-546.
40. Leconte, S, Ferrant, D, Dory, V, & Degryse, J. Validated methods of cough assessment: a systematic review of the literature. Respiration, 81(2), (2010). 161-174.
41. Schmit, KM, Coeytaux, RR, Goode, AP, McCrory, DC, Yancy, WS, Kemper, AR, & Sanders, GD, et al. Evaluating cough assessment tools: a systematic review. CHEST Journal, 144(6), (2013). 1819-1826.
42. Yousaf, N, Lee, KK, Jayaraman, B, Pavord, ID, & Birring, SS. The assessment of quality of life in acute cough with the Leicester Cough Questionnaire (LCQ-acute). Cough, 7(1), (2011). 4.
43. Han, JM, Jung, IC, Kang, W, Kim, SS, Yeo, Y, & Park, YC. Reliability and validity of leicester cough questionnaire Korean version. Chronic respiratory disease, 11(3), (2014). 147-152.